flatbed-scanner-review.org
FLAAR information network
HOME CONTACT US A TO Z INDEX GO DOWN  
 
Scanners    Hardware    Software    Books & links    About FLAAR    FLAAR Reports    Downloads
 

Practical help for choosing a 35mm slide scanner with lists of 35mm film scanners : Polaroid SprintScan 4000, Nikon CoolScan, Minolta, Microtek, Olympus, (35mm slide scanner) manufacturers, makes, models including scanners with Digital ICE.

bizarre mushroom, Peten, Guatemala, Nikon CoolScan of 35mm slide (Leica R3, Leitz macro lens).

For desktop publishing we do not recommend any 35mm slide scanner below 2700 dpi, thus models at lower dpi are not included in our list of 35mm film scanners when a manufacturer has other models at the standard 2700 dpi.

Picture at left: Nikon CoolScan of 35mm slide, mushroom photographed in Peten, Guatemala, Leica R3, Kodachrome film.

The Leaf 35mm slide scanner was discontinued many years ago. Avoid the Leaf Lumina scanner; you do not want the poorly designed and vastly overpriced Lumina at all, not even at a discounted price.

"Software enhanced" dpi is not what you want. If the true optical dpi is 1950, that is all the actual dpi that will show true detail. The rest is wishful thinking.

Manufacturer

Model

Site

Nikon

Super Coolscan LS-1000

nikon.com

We recommend only the Nikon LS-2000 with 2700 dpi; we do not recommend the other Nikon scanners. The 2000, however, is very good, better in many respects than the Polaroid 4000 and the similar Microtek 4000 dpi scanner.

Nikon

Coolscan III

Nikon

Super Cool Scan 2000 (LS-2000)

Nikon

LS-4500 Multi-Format film scanner

LaserSoft Imaging

Scanner software for Nikon

lasersoft-imaging.com

Microtek

ScanMaker 35t Plus

microtek.com

Only 1950 dpi, avoid

Minolta

Dimage Scan Speed

minolta.com

Minolta

Dimage Scan Multi

Olympus

ES-10

olympus.com

Only scans to 1770 dpi

Polaroid

SprintScan 35 Plus

polaroid.com

Polaroid

SprintScan 4000

The Nikon LS-4500 scans 35mm slides at 3000 dpi. This is a 3-pass scanner, which has always evoked comment. It scans 4x5 transparencies only at 1000 dpi, so you would be better off with a Linotype-Hell Saphir Ultra 2 which scans several 4x5 transparencies at a time each at 1200 dpi (especially if you place them in the scanner's sweet spot, down the middle).

The Nikon LS-4500 is based on technology which is several years old, yet it still sells for $6,500. The Polaroid SprintScan 4000, at a reasonable $1995 is, despite its supposedly higher dpi, still not as good as the Nikon 2000 in the dark (shadow) portions of your image. For 4x5 size transparencies you get far superior price point with the Linotype-Hell Saphir Ultra2 (and LinoColor Elite is rated as a superior scanner color management software than what you get with a Nikon). An Imacon is in the high-end price range, but is a professional pre-press film scanning system that is also suitable for desktop publishing and in-house publishing. If you are a power user and prefer the best of the best, consider a Creo EverSmart flatbed scanner.

If you need good quality (professional quality) then you want to scan your 35mm slides either with an Imacon vertical scanner, a Creo EverSmart or a Fuji C-550 Lanovia flatbed scanner (true optical 5000 dpi). The Imacon has an advantage in that SilverFast scanner software is available. The learning curve for SilverFast is a lot softer than the software that is used for prepress. The Imacon, however, is not a drum scanner, a somewhat misleading designation simply because some Imacon models are upright in position, the same position as real drum scanners. But a true drum scanner uses PMT technology; all other scanners, including all Imacon models, use the more economical CCD technology.

Where is a reliable place to buy a 35mm slide scanner? Calumet Photographic is one of many places that sells 35mm slide scanners.

 
Related topics:
 
  NEW FLAAR PREMIUM Report Series on Scanners : Special Offer!
This new FLAAR Series is now available! So click here and purchase it. Or Download the Preview of FLAAR Report Series on Scanners, and learn more about what you can get !

  • Redesign May, 2004
 Creo EverSmart Supreme
EverSmart Pro
35mm slides
Jazz, iQsmart

Cruse 145sl scanner Cruse repro scanner
 Other Repro Stand Scanners
Kaiser repro stand
ZBE repro stand
Related Links

C-550 Lanovia review
C-550 Lanovia test drive
Museum quality scanner
 Wide Format Scanners
ACTion Imaging Colortrac FB24120
CST, Screen, and Colortrac
List of Wide Format Scanners
Comments on Wide Format Scanners
 Prepress Scanners
Cezanne, Screen USA
Creo , iQsmart
Flatbed scanners for prepress
  Drum Scanners
About drum scanners
Accesories
List of drum scanners
ICG Drum scanner details
35mm Slide Scanners
 Flatbed Scanners
Epson
Exhibit quality scanning
Scanning 3D objects
Used flatbed scanners
Related Links

  Other Scanners
Agfa-Microtek
Imacon 4x5

Purup-Eskofot

Purup-Eskofot 1318
Scanview
Heidelberg Scanners
Linotype-Hell Saphir Ultra2

Recommended scanners
Questions and answers
Scanner examples
Scanner accesories
FLAAR Reports on Scanners

    Related FLAAR Report
scanning slides and negatives

Learn more
As part of the FLAAR Premium Reports on Photo Quality

Table bottom

Most of our updates for November 2004 onward are in FLAAR Reports in Adobe Acrobat PDF format. It is more efficient for us to make new information available in PDF format. So if the web page itself is not updated, check out www.wide-format-printers.NET to see if the printer, RIP, or other subject is covered in an update in a PDF download.

 
VISIT OTHER FLAAR RELATED WEBSITES :
 
 
About Us
Who and What is FLAAR ?
About FLAAR Reports
Privacy Statement
Legal Advisory
FLAAR Policies
Contact Us
Contact us
Premium FLAAR Reports
Consulting Service

About the site
Home
Site map
A to Z index
FAQ

GO UP

Help
Technical comment about the site contact site webmaster.
If you note an error, omission, or have a different opinion on a review, contact the review editor, Dr. Nicholas Hellmuth.
 

flatbed-scanner-review.org is part of the FLAARnetwork© 2001-2004